Sunday, June 13, 2010

Delicious Vietnam #2 - Blind banh mi battle

"Move back!  I can't see!"

"Get off me!  You're totally in the way!"

"No, you are, you freak... Oh my god, you made me miss Ba Le's power pâté punch!  I'm gonna kill you!"

"Oh yeah?  You just wait, I'm gonna...  Whoa!  The cucumber screwdriver!"

"What?  Move!  I can't see!  

"You move!  What, it's over?  Who won?"

"You totally ruined it!  Take that!"

As the old black and white TV flickers, two brothers and their cousin wrestle on the floor, replaying the epic struggle they have just witnessed.  The battle of the banh mi is being waged again, this time between beefy twins Footscray and Richmond, as their little cousin Preston - small yet feisty - lands a lucky punch or two.  As the coffee table is knocked over and the glasses of soda go flying, the boys are a blur of arms and legs, and it's impossible to tell one from the other.

We are so lucky here in Melbourne, Australia, to have a number of Vietnamese neighbourhoods woven into the fabric of our city.  Melbourne loves her Vietnamese sons.  Which plucky young one will win the blind banh mi battle?

For this month's Delicious Vietnam, the brainchild of Anh of A Food Lover's Journey and Hong & Kim of Ravenous Couple, I want to share with you our latest Melbourne food blogger meetup and homage to one of Melbourne's best-loved Vietnamese imports - the banh mi.  Following the success of #balutfest and the victory of favourite son Springvale in the hot vit lon department, Billy of Half-Eaten had the brilliant idea of arranging a blind banh mi taste test to judge which bakery made the best pork roll.  The blind testing was crucial to eliminate local bias. Not that yours truly would suffer from that AT ALL...  :)

Banh mi fixings.  From left to right: gio lua, char siu, "jellymeat"

Banh mi are a Vietnamese take on a classic French sandwich.  They can have many fillings, like BBQ chicken, meatballs, roast pork, or even tofu, but the classic is banh mi thit nguoi or "mixed ham roll."  This starts with a crunchy bread roll, which is deftly sliced and spread with a chiaroscuro of flavour - a shimmering streak of pale egg mayo (aka "butter") on one side, and rich, dark pâté on the other.  Three kinds of ham are normally added - gio lua, a pale Vietnamese "sausage" of pounded pork, often seen in a banana leaf-wrapped cylinder; char siu or Chinese-style BBQ pork, often with a red edge; and a type of head cheese (affectionately known by us as "jellymeat"), which is various porky odds and ends, pressed together and bound with aspic.  The meaty trio is topped with sweet pickled carrots, often mixed with similarly pickled white radish or onion; cucumber; coriander/cilantro; fresh chilli; and a sprinkle of Maggi sauce.

I arrived at the our "kitchen stadium" (penny aka jeroxie's cosy kitchen) and added my wager of 6 rolls from Footscray's finest bakeries to the growing pile on the table.  We started nervously at the piles of banh mi, dormant in their white paper packages.  Billy had devised an ingenious "blind tasting" system where all tasters would be unaware of the provenance of each roll.  With a nervous gulp of tea, we began our quest, slowly munching our way through 18 carefully segmented sandwiches.  Screwed up noses contrasted with emphatic nodding of heads as carrot and crumbs piled up in our laps like a snowdrift.

What I discovered was the best sandwiches began with good bread.  For me, banh mi cannot be made with regular, Australian-style white bread that is thick, chewy, and with a soft crust.  My favourite rolls had crackly crusts that shattered when you bit in, covering you in a confetti of crumbs and crust.  The interior of the bread should be quite airy and with an open crumb, so the filling takes centre stage.  The meat had to be fresh, tasty, and not too fatty; the pâté rich, non-grainy, and equally distributed; and the salad zingy with sweet vinegar, but not overpowering.

Banh mi sushi!

Sports fans - there was a clear winner.  Both everyone's individual top score and our totalled combined top score pointed to Nhu Lan of Footscray as the far and away victor!  In my own notes, Nhu Lan scored full marks for their excellent crusty bread and fresh, balanced ham combination.  I deducted marks for salad and overall flavour, which I find somewhat bemusing as I often buy a salad-only banh mi from Nhu Lan, so enamored am I of their pickled carrots.  This little shop is the busiest bakery in Footscray by far, and it's also the most expensive, at $3.80 for a banh mi thit nguoi compared to $3.20 - $3.50 elsewhere.  But let's be serious - for such freshness, flavour, and variety, how can you call $3.80 expensive?!

On the scorecard above, the numbers along the top correspond to the following bakeries.  You can see each taster's individual scores, and the numbers in circles down the bottom are the bakeries' overall rankings.

1 - Lee Lee (Victoria St, Richmond)
2 - Huong Huong (Victoria St, Richmond)
3 - Tina (High St, Preston)
4 - Nhu Lan (Hopkins St, Footscray)
5 - To's (Little Saigon Market, Footscray)
6 - Phuoc Thanh (Victoria St, Richmond)
7 - Mai Lan (High St, Preston)
8 - Saigon Bakery (Victoria St, Richmond)
9 - Ba Le (Leeds St, Footscray)

That night, a battle was waged in my belly.  Over twenty-seven different pieces of ham roiled in a sea of egg butter, and a single, crisp green apple was all I could manage for dinner.  This fighter is hanging up her banh mi boots.

What's that?  You're off to Nhu Lan?  Oh, go on.  I'll have a banh mi with BBQ chicken.  Hey, I'm always up for a rematch.

Thank you Billy for organising the battle and to Penny for hosting it.  I look forward to future food forays!


  1. How exciting! I shall have to make a trip down to Footscray myself. I'm more than a little cut up about not being able to turn up that day. But hopefully there will be other battles, and further foodie meet ups!

  2. Sounds delicious! But no N Lee? (this is how round two starts you know!)

  3. Glad the winning dish is in Footscray! Banh mi is on my ever growing list of things to try so at least I don't have too far to travel to get a prizewinner! That's a fair workload on the digestive system too by the look of things.

  4. what an awesome idea to do with banh mi lovers! thank you for the submission!

  5. Awesome round up. I am so behind my post yet again... nice inclusion to the 2nd edition of Delicious Vietnam :)

  6. Now that sounds like fun! Woohoo for Nhu Lan!! I walked past there about an hour ago! ;-) I decided to try out Dumplings and More today, based on your recent post. The seaweed salad sure had a spicy kick! In all, it made for a nice lunch for me and hubby, dumplings and the lamb skewers as well! Thanks!

  7. How fantastic, I'm in Cabra, but when I'm in Melb for work next will try Lee Lee... what a great idea to do a test of banh mi thit!

  8. Ha! Richmond is a win :P. Great post, and I wish I could join you guy.

    What about a pho hunting? lol

  9. Oh, misread, was reading too early, prizewinner is not in footscray. Oops. Still will try Nhu Lan at some stage and maybe try the Richmond winner for a comparison. Excuse my dufferness. A pho-off would be interesting to see though.

  10. Celeste - we missed you! Hope your housemate was OK. I am jealous of all the home-cooked amazing food you must be eating in Malaysia right now!

    Essjayeff - you're on!!! :)

    Deb - no, you read right - it is Nhu Lan of Footscray. They have another branch in Richmond, which might have added to the confusion. Not sure if it is as good, though!

    Ravenous Couple - we had a ball! Thank you for hosting the event!

    Penny - thank you for letting us drop crumbs all over your kitchen. Looking forward to reading your writeup, too!

    Kurichan - when I got your comment originally, Mr Baklover had literally just gotten back from buying a hangover banh mi from Nhu Lan, so you may have unwittingly crossed paths! Glad you liked Dumplings & More. I hope the "spicy kick" was a good thing! ;)

    Thang - I'm dying to go to Cabra. Was talking to a friend who knows it quite well and she said it's Footscray in overdrive. Hope you enjoy Lee Lee!

    Anh - wished you could have been there! I am sooo up for pho hunting. Just let me know time and place and I am there. :)

  11. I'm thinking Essjay might be right - we not only missed N Lee, but also Kenny's, Sunny's, N Tran (of Chapel St) and all of Springvale... but it might be best to give ourselves a couple of months to recover - and write up our posts!

  12. Hi Billy - yes, a couple of months to recover is a very good call! We could take the top 3 from this battle and then have all the new "challengers" from the bakeries we missed. Yeah!!

  13. You should have try the one in springvale, 164 anthol rd, Springvale, Victoria.
    it has the tastiest pate and mayonaise..

  14. Anon - thanks for the rec! We did originally also have reps from Springvale and Collingwood coming, but they had to pull out at the last minute. I will remember this one for next time!

  15. I totally didn't eat dinner that evening, great write-up. Ah the memories - atomic pink pate (too lazy to put all the appropriate accents on the word), Penny's dog trying to steal snatches of the yumminess...a capital way to spend a Sunday afternoon!

  16. An Loi (under Gold Leaf restaurant) in Springvale makes the best ones. There is always a queue for these pork rolls! When there's a queue you know the ingredients will always be fresh!

  17. Send your team to Sunshine and St Albans for a scout before the next battle. There's quite a few out that way worth trying.

    1. We are probably due a battle #2, Bill! Do you have any particular recommendations for Sunshine and Snorbens?


I love getting your comments! They're what make blogging worthwhile. Unfortunately, the amount of spam I get is obscene and it is so tiresome to have to moderate every comment, so I have had to turn on annoying word verification. I'm sorry for the inconvenience, but please know how much I love you having your say!

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Related Posts with Thumbnails